Working Out What a Dessert Costs and What to Charge for It
Most home bakers work out cost as the sum of what the receipt says, and are then surprised that the work brings in no money. Ingredients usually account for between a third and a half of the real cost. The rest is everything that never reaches a receipt but is spent every single time.
Below is a formula in five parts. There are deliberately no actual prices here: they differ by city and change every month. Use your own.
Part one: ingredients, including waste
Not the weight in the recipe but the weight you bought. The gap comes from three places.
Process losses. What stays in the bowl, on the spatula, on the sides of the pan. Sponge trimmings when levelling. Mousse left in the piping bag. In practice you lose 5 to 15 % depending on the piece — more on entremets, less on baked goods.
Indivisible packs. A 50 g packet of gelatine when a cake uses 8 g. Either the remainder goes into later orders — in which case it has to be spread across them — or it spoils, and then the whole packet lands on this order.
Failures. Not every piece works first time. If on average one in ten is remade, that is another 10 % on ingredients across all of them.
A practical move: calculate ingredients from the recipe and multiply by 1.15 to 1.2. That is closer to the truth than counting grams precisely.
Part two: depreciation
A stand mixer, moulds, rings, a thermometer, an airbrush — all of it wears out and will one day need replacing.
The arithmetic is simple: the cost of the equipment divided by its expected life in months, and that figure divided by the average number of orders per month.
The shape of the calculation: if equipment costing a notional hundred units lasts three years and twenty orders pass through you each month, depreciation is a hundred divided by thirty-six divided by twenty — a small sum per order, but a noticeable one over a year.
Consumables belong here too: parchment, film, acetate strip, gloves, bags, nozzles. Count them not per item but as a monthly spend divided by the number of orders.
Part three: an hour of your time
The part most often skipped. Your own labour has to be paid for, or you are not producing — you are subsidising.
Count all the time, not just time at the bench:
- Shopping and travel.
- Preparation: weighing, preheating, preparing moulds.
- Production itself, including waiting between stages if you cannot do anything else meanwhile.
- Assembly and decoration.
- Cleaning up — it takes longer than people assume.
- Dealing with the customer, agreeing details, messaging.
The rate is yours to set. A reasonable starting point is what you would accept per hour working for someone else in the same trade. Not less.
Part four: packaging and delivery
Box, board, ribbon, topper, bag. For entremets, ice packs and an insulated bag.
Delivery is its own line and should not hide inside the price of the cake: either the customer pays for it, or you know exactly what it costs you. Fuel, time on the road and the risk of damage are all real expenses.
Part five: margin
The sum of the first four is your cost — the point at which you have earned nothing. Price starts above it.
Margin covers everything that cannot be attributed to a single order: time spent learning and ingredients for trial pieces, photography and social media, cancelled orders, tax, and growth. Plus actual profit.
The practical range in a small pastry business is from 100 % over cost upward. Below 100 % the business will not survive its first bad month.
The formula
Price = (ingredients × 1.15 + depreciation + consumables + hours × rate + packaging) × margin multiplier, with delivery as a separate line.
Three questions that come up most
Do I count the trial piece? If you are making a new item for the first time, the ingredients and time for the trial go into margin and are spread across future orders of that item, rather than being hung on the first customer.
Volume discounts. Justified only where time is genuinely saved: ten identical pastries are quicker than ten different ones. The saving on ingredients is close to zero, and the discount should not pretend otherwise.
Rush orders. A surcharge for urgency is not greed but compensation: a rush order displaces others and takes away your ability to plan.
A spreadsheet built once takes ten minutes to update when prices move — and it settles the question of what to charge for a cake for good.